my (ongoing, abridged) list of which pet forms drop which items. all forms of the pet should drop the item/s beside its stamp*, with any special cases listed below. *or egg name, if there's no stamp yet

the original, unabridged post has been moved to the first reply, and both lists will be updated as necessary.


- scales
(chance of snow in your area) - blue claws
(spicy noodle) - red claws

- fur, fairy dust
(flower power) - vibrant flower

- shell fragment, red claws
(the carapace is still squishy) - shell fragment [exclusively?]
(rock beats scissors but why not both) - ancient gem

- fur, blue claws
(born for stardom) - fairy dust
(the mittens are for doing mischief) - fur [exclusively?]

- thick gel
(deviled egg) - blue claws
(eggplant) - fruit salad, vine

- dark ink [likely; TBD]
(fluttering ominously) - fur
(the sound of rattling bones) - scales, blue claws, shiny coin, dark ink
(snipping hazard) - dark ink, blue claws
(danger: sharp objects) - dark ink

chilly egg - feather

spiky egg - shell fragment, possibly also scales
(pebble) - scales
(let me be crystal clear with you) - clear crystal, ancient gem
(prickly exterior) - scales, red claws
(hugs not recommended) - red claws

sneaky egg - fur
(quicksilver) - thick gel [fur drop TBD?]

lumps - fur

thief bag - feather, fur, scales, fairy dust, shell fragment, red claws, blue claws, beady eye, dark ink, bread, shiny coin, paper, vibrant flower


anyone is welcome to chip in info; keep in mind that thief bags "[have] a chance to produce random items for the pet's owner during socialization", i.e. grooming and socialization drops aren't affected, but room drops give unreliable data if they have any thief bags

hooray for casual talking forums!!! thank you to all the beautiful mods for your time!!!!

with the new system for pet drops, i want to try and keep track of which pet drops what when (but i mostly have dragons rn so.)(soft restart bc i forgot thief bags would affect the drops o)-( alas but we persevere)


(shh, sleep is happening) - scales
(flap flap) - scales
(flap flap flap) - scales
(looking sharp!) - scales
(FLAP FLAP FLAP) - scales
(one head, two tails, not valid for coin flips) - scales
(chance of snow in your area) - scales, blue claws
(spicy noodle) - scales, red claws


(dandelion puff) - fur
(natural habitat: pollen) - fur, fairy dust
(dandelion fluff) - fairy dust, fur
(flying off into the sunset) - fairy dust, fur
(flies into you affectionately) - fur, fairy dust
(flower power) - fur, fairy dust, vibrant flower
(drifting along the wind) - fairy dust, fur
(only you can cause forest fires) - fur, fairy dust


(the carapace is still squishy) - shell fragment
(snip snip) - shell fragment, red claws
(things are going swimmingly) - shell fragment, red claws
(the blue spots warn predators that this one doesn't want to be eaten) - shell fragment, red claws
(rock beats scissors but why not both) - shell fragment, red claws, ancient gem
(a light in the darkness) - shell fragment, red claws
(rough seas ahead) - shell fragment, red claws


(ready to pounce) - fur, blue claws
(you hear an odd rumbling sound) - fur, blue claws
(you hear a soft rumbling sound) - fur, blue claws
(born for stardom) - fur, blue claws, fairy dust
(there's no scratching post big enough) - fur, blue claws
(floof) - fur, blue claws
(the mittens are for doing mischief) - fur


(oops) - thick gel
(what) - thick gel
(deviled egg) - blue claws, thick gel
(water you doing here) - thick gel
(this sure is an animal) - thick gel
(space-efficient!) - thick gel
(eggplant) - thick gel, fruit salad, vine
(laying egg) - thick gel
(mithreesis) - thick gel


(fluttering ominously) - fur
(the sound of rattling bones) - scales, blue claws, shiny coin, dark ink
(snipping hazard) - dark ink, blue claws
(danger: sharp objects) - dark ink

chilly egg
(pocket size) - feather
(multipurpose: runs, swims, and slides on ice) - feather
(no flavor text - lighting affinity?) - feather
(fighting spirit) - feather
(does a silly little dance to impress you) - feather
(relax, this is only a drill) - feather

spiky egg
(pebble) - scales, shell fragment
(let me be crystal clear with you) - shell fragment, clear crystal, ancient gem
(prickly exterior) - shell fragment, scales, red claws
(hugs not recommended) - shell fragment, red claws
(aloe there!) - shell fragment

sneaky egg
(built-in blanket) - fur
(at least 80% tail by volume (but not weight)) - fur
(this thing should not have been trusted with thumbs) - fur
(quicksilver) - thick gel
(sky pirate) - fur
(winter coat) - fur

lumps - fur

thief bag - feather, fur, scales, fairy dust, shell fragment, red claws, blue claws, beady eye, dark ink, bread, shiny coin, paper, vibrant flower

Grooming and socialization drops are based on the specific form of the pet; different forms of the same species frequently have slightly different drops.

@EpiglottalAxolotl oooh okay i see! fascinating, thank you 👀

Still-growing Normal Egg drops Thick Gel when groomed :]

@Say0rnis ooh i'll add that, thank u! :]

Also, keep in mind that if there is a thief bag in the room, the pet's owner will sometimes get random items unrelated to the pet's species. Any item drops that feel like they don't make sense are coming from the thief bag, most likely.

@EpiglottalAxolotl oh wait that's true... gonna go take out all my thieves bags now--

I suspect the Mysterious Brew'd void-element pets drop Dark Ink, my (snipping hazard) pet (currently my forum icon) just dropped one

@Say0rnis agree! i have a devious brew-ed dragon pet and it's dropped dark ink before 👍

My born for stardom kitty cat dropped fairy dust while brushing today!

The "quicksilver" sneaky egg gives thick gel when groomed!

The "space-efficient" normal egg also gives thick gel!

@Wildy fascinating... :0 i don't think my starcat has ever dropped fairy dust?? i wonder if a thief bag influences grooming or if it's just a rare drop,, i'll add it with a (?) until we have further evidence aklsdjfa;lskfj ty for letting me know! :)

@Hypercube34 thank you!! yeah it seems like the default drop for normal eggs is thick gel, but good to know about the quicksilver sneaky egg :)